1. Cutler A. - Kazhdan A., "Lips", in A. Kazhdan (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium 2 (New York - Oxford 1991) 1232-1233 and Cutler A. - Talbot A.-M., "Lips Monastery", in A. Kazhdan (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium 2 (New York - Oxford 1991)1233; Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1254. 2. On Constantine Lips, see Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 256; Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 299-300; Cutler A. - Kazhdan A., "Lips", in A. Kazhdan (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium 2 (New York - Oxford 1991) 1232; and Marinis V., The Monastery tou Libos: Architecture, Sculpture, and Liturgical Planning in Middle and Late Byzantine Constantinople (PhD Diss., University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 2005) 23-27, 29-31. 3. The renovation of the monastery is vaguely implied by the words of Scylitzes "τὴν καινουργηθεĩσαν παρ' αὐτοῦ μονήν". Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 255 accepted this thesis and elaborated it further on the following pages of his study. Although the excavations of the 1960s yielded no evidence for existence of remains of earlier structures below the present church, Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 280 leaves the possibility open. 4. As shown by Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 280 ff. 5. A fragmentarily preserved verse inscription, carved on a cornice that runs along the exterior of the three central apses, mentions a certain Constantine, who dedicated the church to the Mother of God “Πανάχραντος”. For the fullest reconstruction of the inscription’s text, see Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 300-301. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 259 also described the central door lintel with three discs bearing monograms, one of which he read as "Constantine". 6. Συνεχισταί Θεοφάνους, Χρονογραφία, Bekker I. (ed.), Theophanes Continuatus (Bonn 1838) p. 371, 12-18. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 256, n. 17; Gerstel S. E., "Saint Eudokia and the Imperial Household of Leo VI", The Art Bulletin 79 (1997) 706, n. 61. For the date of the inauguration of the monastery, see Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 300. 7. Πάτρια Κωνσταντινουπόλεως, Preger Th. (ed.), Scriptores originum Constantinopolitanarum (Leipzig 1901; repr. New York 1975) p. 289. This source, however, is not considered reliable; see Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1254 and Cutler A. - Kazhdan A., "Lips", in A. Kazhdan (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium 2 (New York - Oxford 1991) 1232. 8. The typikon has been preserved in a luxury codex, British Library Additional 22748 (14th c.), which is probably its original version; cf. Talbot A.-M., "Empress Theodora Palaiologina, Wife of Michael VIII", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 46 (1992) 301. The Greek text of the typikon was published by Delehaye H., Deux typica byzantins de l’époque des Paléologues (Brussels 1921) 106-136. An English translation with notes is in Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1265-1286. For the date when the typikon was written, see Talbot A.-M., "Empress Theodora Palaiologina, Wife of Michael VIII", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 46 (1992) 299. 9. Typikon, article 4, Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1267. 10. Typikon, articles 1 and 50, Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1265, 1281. 11. Mango C., Byzantine Architecture (New York 1976) 266. 12. Talbot A.-M., "Empress Theodora Palaiologina, Wife of Michael VIII", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 46 (1992) 302, n. 67. 13. Theodora prescribed in the typikon, article 42, Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1278 a place in the Church of St. John for her own and her mother's tomb and mentioned that her daughter had already been buried in the same church. In the same article she made allowances for her children and grandchildren to be buried in the church if they express a desire to do so. For the burials of Andronikos II and his brother Constantine, see Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1254-1255, n. 9. 14. See Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 270 (n. 57), and Marinis V., The Monastery tou Libos: Architecture, Sculpture, and Liturgical Planning in Middle and Late Byzantine Constantinople (PhD Diss., University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 2005) 22. Remnants of a wall painting were discovered in the westernmost arcosolium by Mango C.- Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Finds at Fenari Isa Camii, Istanbul", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 22 (1968) 178, who dated it to ca. 1320. 15. Cf. Cutler A. - Talbot A.-M., "Lips Monastery", in A. Kazhdan (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium 2 (New York - Oxford 1991) 1233. 16. Typikon, articles 37 and 39, Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1276-1277; Ψευδο-Κωδινός, Περί των οφφικίων, Verpeaux J. (ed.), Pseudo-Kodinos, Traité des offices (Le monde byzantin 1, Paris 1966) p. 242, 15-17. 17. Majeska G., Russian Travelers to Constantinople in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries (Washington DC 1984) 310-311. 18. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 253; Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1255. The tombs located in the former Church of St. John were opened and cleared of human remains, as prescribed by Islamic laws pertaining to the establishment of a mosque. 19. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 253. 20. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 253-54; Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1255. 21. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 253-54; Thomas J. - Hero A. C., Byzantine Monastic Foundation Documents. A Complete Translation of Surviving Founders' Typika and Testaments (Washington DC 2000) 1255. 22. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 251 (Mango's comments). 23. The subdivision of the preserved dome cornice, marked with six eagles, suggests that the original drum was pierced by either six or twelve windows: cf. Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 306-307. 24. Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 288; Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 306. 25. The foundations of this porch were recorded within both surveys, of 1929 and 1960s. For an ideal reconstruction, see Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 295. 26. Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 294-95. 27. The gallery communicates visually with the naos through a triple arcade; cf. Krautheimer R., Early Christian and Byzantine Architecture (New Haven - London 1986) 358-359. 28. Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 290-291. In a series of articles, Nikolai Brunov reconstructed the church as having additional aisles along each lateral side: cf. Brunov N., "Zum Problem des Kreuzkuppelsystems", Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik 16 (1967) 245-261 and Брунов Н., "К вопросу о средневековой архитектуре Константинополя", Византийский временник 28 (1968) 159-191. According to him, the roof terraces on top of these aisles provided access to the second-floor parekklēsia. For the most recent discussion of the problem whether there were outer aisles or not, see Marinis V., The Monastery tou Libos: Architecture, Sculpture, and Liturgical Planning in Middle and Late Byzantine Constantinople (PhD Diss., University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 2005) 8, 44-58. 29. Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 292. At each of the two eastern chapels, Megaw saw "remains of a substantial stone foundation of octagonal form standing on the pendentives", which he considered the base of a drum. However, published and unpublished photographs, taken during the survey, show no evidence whatsoever regarding the stone foundation reported by Megaw. Cf. also Marinis V., The Monastery tou Libos: Architecture, Sculpture, and Liturgical Planning in Middle and Late Byzantine Constantinople (PhD Diss., University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 2005) 62-63, who does not see a reason for domes to be placed over the antechambers of the western chapels instead over their sanctuary areas. 30. Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 286. 31. This plan, known from Early Byzantine times on, was revived in Middle Byzantine architecture (e.g. the core of the Pammakaristos Church). Whether it had survived or was revived again in the 13th century remains open; cf. Krautheimer R., Early Christian and Byzantine Architecture (New Haven - London 1986) 417, 423. 32. Originally, between the four corner piers there were three pairs of columns, which were part of triple arcades opening to the ambulatory. Four out of six column bases were found by Macridy under the Ottoman floor; Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 265-266. Original triple arcades were filled up in one of the several Ottoman reconstructions of the building, but their steep arches are still discernable: Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 266. The present dome is also the result of a rebuilding (ibidem). 33. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 266. One can still see the holes where the legs of the altar table were fixed, as well as the slots for a marble templon. 34. Only two fragments remain: Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 267. 35. There are remnants of mosaic decoration in the arcosolia of the ambulatory's south arm: Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 267. 36. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 265. 37. The perambulatory was not built integrally with the south church, as the joint of their eastern walls demonstrates: cf. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 267. 38. The present rough finish of the perambulatory's northwest corner suggests that originally it may have enveloped the complex on the north side as well. See Megaw A. H. S., "The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 287-88. 39. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 268; Mango C.- Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Finds at Fenari Isa Camii, Istanbul", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 22 (1968) 177-178. 40. Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 304. 41. See Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) passim, and Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) passim. 42. See Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 309-310. 43. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 273-75. For a possible historical context of this icon, see Gerstel S. E., "Saint Eudokia and the Imperial Household of Leo VI", The Art Bulletin 79 (1997) 699-707. 44. Mango C. - Hawkins E. J. W., "Additional Notes on the Monastery of Lips", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 310-11; Mango M. M., "Polychrome Tiles Found at Istanbul: Typology, Chronology, and Function", in Gerstel S. E. - Lauffenburger J. A. (eds.), A Lost Art Rediscovered: The Architectural Ceramics of Byzantium (Baltimore 2001) 13-41. 45. Macridy T., "The Monastery of Lips and the Burials of the Palaeologi", Dumbarton Oaks Papers 18 (1964) 252 (Mango's comments). Both the archivolt and the inlaid icon of St. Eudokia are now in the Istanbul Archaeological Museum. |